158
chapter five
recognized final-status issues including illegal Jewish settlements, the
return of refugees, recognized borders and the status of Jerusalem.16 As
Cook points out, rather unlike other nation-states, Israel is not asking its
Palestinian counterparts to recognize its territorial borders, sovereignty or
even its democratic identity. Instead, it is strictly asking for formal recognition of its ‘Jewish’ character.
Research on Palestinians in Israel: An Overview
The relationship between Palestinian-Arabness and Zionism, founded on
an interaction of political rejection and non-identification, has produced
a range of critical scholarship. This research, from Arab, Jewish and
Western sources, has sought to conceptualize the particular features, uses
and dynamics of the citizenship bestowed to Palestinian-Arabs in Israel.
Put together, these scholars are attempting to deconstruct the internal
contradictions and paradoxes that arise, both conceptually and in practice, with the state’s provision of Israeli citizenship to Palestinian-Arabs
on the one hand, and with its unabridged fusing of ‘Israeli’ and ‘Jewish’
identity and nationhood on the other. The scholarly literature largely
agrees that the most important factor in delineating the contours of the
relationship between Israel and Palestinian-Arab citizens is the constitutional and practical ethnic exclusivity of the state. Viewing this selfdefinitionas a significant determinant of the relationship between the
State of Israel and the Palestinian-Arab community, most critical scholars
agree that Israel’s institutional and structural components leave them
with mere citizenship status, or citizenship in the law. As a result, most
scholars point to a paradox that emerges with the simplistic designation
of this community as citizens with a citizenship. They argue that the
self-identification of the state as an essentially Jewish state, with a Jewish
identity, and a demographic caveat requiring a Jewish majority within the
territories of Israeli control complicates, but does not cut, political,
national, identity and membership ties between the state and the
Palestinian-Arab citizenry. From this, many continue to posit that, in the
case of the Palestinian-Arabs in Israel, the constitutional self-definition of
the state as Jewish, and its repeated need for the adoption of structural
and institutional policies of dominance and control, essentially repudiates the citizenship of this community. As such, to say that Arabs in Israel
16 Cook, “Israel’s Jewishness.”
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents