20
THE QUESTION OF PALESTINE
for the Paris Pcace C onference, Sylvain L6vi (a distinguished
French Orientalist— the profession is important for the argu
ment o f this book) spoke on behalf o f the Zionist delegation;
he argued “ that, though the work o f the Zionists was o f great
significance from the moral point o f view, Palestine was a small
and poor land with a population o f 600,000 A rabs, and the
[incoming] Jews, having a higher standard o f living, would tend
to dispossess th e m ."’" A ccording to Weizmann, this embar
rassed the Zionists since, as he was later to say, “ the world
would judge the Jewish state [and presumably the Zionist
movement] by what it shall do with the A ra b s,” 19 For indeed it
was the world that made the success o f Zionism possible, and it
was Zionism ’s sense o f the world as supporter and audience
that played a considerable practical role in the struggle for
Palestine.
Not all the world had Balfour’s callous disregard o f natives,
although it is also true that during the late nineteenth and early
twentieth centuries even anti-imperialists like John Hobson
believed in the existence o f “ subject races” whose opinions did
not count very high on a list o f priorities. Nevertheless the
Zionists and even the British knew that somehow the natives
would appear— and by appear I mean something little more
than that the natives would become physically perceptible, if
nothing else, to observers—-and by appearing would make
their resistance known to the world. It was not lost on the
British and the Zionists that according to the finest A rab study
o f the struggle for independence ( The Arab Awakening by
G eorge Antonius), the A rab renaissance would make Arabs
aware o f the impossible contradiction between their plans for
themselves and for their territory (including Palestine, of
course) and the plans advanced by Balfour, the Zionists, and
the French. M oreover, most of the Jews of the w orld, then as
now, were not in Palestine but in “ the w orld," defined as the
European/American world. The task then became to convert
Palestine into a Jewish state, without at the same time making
it possible for the world to take seriously (or even later to know
about) the natives' protest. T he systematic denial o f a substan
tial native A rab presence in Palestine was accom panied, as I
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents