KJ
THE y l LSIION OK PALESTINE
The "in ven tory" o f Palestinian experience that I am trying to
take here is based on the simple truth that the exultant or
(later) the terrorized Jews who arrived in Palestine were seen
essentially as foreigners whose proclaimed destiny was to
create a state for Jews. What o f the Arabs who were there? was
the question we must feel ourselves asking now. What we will
discover is that everything positive from the Zionist standpoint
looked absolutely negative from the perspective of the native
A rab Palestinians.
For they could never be fit into the grand vision. Not that
"vision " was m erely a theoretical matter; it was that and, as it
was later to determine the character and even the details of
Israeli government policy toward the native Arah Palestinians,
“ vision" was also the way Zionist leaders looked at the Arabs
in order later (and certainly at that moment) to deal with them.
Thus, as I said earlier, I have in mind the whole dialectic
between theory and actual day-to-day effectiveness. My prem
ise is that Israel developed as a social polity out of the Zionist
thesis that Palestine’s colonization was to be accomplished
simultaneously for and by Jews and by the displacement of the
Palestinians; m oreover, that in its conscious and declared ideas
about Palestine, Zionism attempted first to minimize, then to
elim inate, and then, all else failing, finally to subjugate the
natives as a way o f guaranteeing that Israel would not be
simply the state o f its citizens (which included Arabs, of
course) but the state o f “ the whole Jewish peop le," having a
kind of sovereignty over land and peoples that no other state
possessed or possesses, (t is this anom aly that the Arab
Palestinians have since been trying both to resist and provide
an alternative for.
One can learn a great deal from pronouncements made by
strategically important Zionist leaders whose job it was, after
Herzl, to translate the design into action. Chaim Weizmann
comes to mind at once, as much for his extraordinary person
ality as for his brilliant successes in bringing Zionism up from
an idea to a conquering political institution. His thesis about
the land o f Palestine is revealing in the extent to which it
repeats Herzl:
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents