International. R. at 99-101. She has traveled to Kazakhstan to investigate revocation and denial of Kazak citizenship individuals. Ms. and the Lynch plight contends of stateless that ethnic minorities, especially Chechens, are disfavored in Kazakhstan and discriminated against with regards to obtaining or maintaining Kazak citizenship. R. at 99-101. Other reports presented by Petitioners support Ms. Lynch’s expert testimony, asserting that the Kazak government uses citizenship as a political tool to keep certain ethnic groups oppressed, prevent them from voting, and subject them to other bureaucratic persecution, such as denying them the right to work, the right to enroll in public school, the right to travel freely, the right to identity documents, and the right to state-funded services. The Petitioners contend that they, too, have been victims of the 30 Kazak government’s