I. STATEMENT OF JURISDICTION
Petitioners,
Boris,
Tatiana,
Natalia,
and
Polina Jourbina, seek review of an order of the
Board of Immigration Appeals (BIA) dated March 22,
2011
that
dismissed
the
Petitioners’
Motion
Reopen Removal Proceedings. Add. at 45-48.
action
challenges
the
BIA’s
to
This
arbitrary
and
capricious dismissal of the motion on the grounds
that:
the
agency
failed
properly
to
address—and
thus perfunctorily dismissed—the Petitioners’ claim
that their recent denationalization because of nonKazak nationality constitutes a change in country
conditions in their native Kazakhstan, the central
basis
for
erroneously
the
Motion
reduced
nationalization
claim
to
the
as
one
Reopen;
the
agency
Petitioners’
of
de-
“statelessness”
arising from non-discriminatory acts;
the agency
failed to provide any reasoning or legal analysis
when
dismissing
the
Petitioners’
prima facie asylum proffer.
5
arguments
and