Detention
“Stateless persons are also uniquely vulnerable to prolonged detention and States
should be sensitized to respect the rights
of stateless persons to be free from arbitrary detention as a result of their stateless
status”.
Ban Ki-moon,
U.N. Secretary-General
Guidance Note of the Secretary General:
The United Nations and Statelessness,
June 2011
The majority of stateless people encountered
by UNHCR in the United States have a final
order of removal issued against them and
have therefore spent some period of time in
immigration detention awaiting removal from
the United States. Most of these individuals
have experienced tremendous emotional
trauma during detention, including the stress
of detention itself, the removal from their daily life, transfers to different immigration detention facilities away from their homes and
communities, the uncertainty of how long
they will be detained since no country recognizes them, and fears about being sent to a
country with which they have no connection.
Because stateless individuals have no country that recognizes them as citizens, they
are rarely accepted to another country for
removal and are often detained beyond the
90-day removal period. For these individuals,
their only recourse is often to file a habeas
corpus petition with a federal district court,
a measure which is time-consuming, difficult for someone without familiarity with U.S.
laws, and one that they may only learn about
after having spent substantial time in detention. Some stateless individuals are released
from detention only to be detained again at
a later time,116 often without warning, leaving
others remain fearful that this will happen to
them.
Solutions for the Stateless in the U.S.
Detention Takes Its Toll
Viktorya N., a woman with a thriving small business in California, came to the United States
in 1990 from the Ukrainian Soviet Socialist Republic of the former Soviet Union.117 Following
a final order of removal against her, she was
detained, but her removal order could not be
executed because the Soviet Union had ceased
to exist and neither Russia nor Ukraine would
recognize her as a national. She remained in
detention for three months and experienced
significant trauma—not only by her detention but also by the great uncertainty of what
would happen to her and where she might be
sent. She spent weeks wondering who would
take her, knowing that she was not a citizen
of any country, and imagining that some country would accept her as a favor to the United
States and she would be forced to move there.
After several months in detention, she wrote a
letter explaining why she believed no country
would ever accept her. She was eventually released but continues to face restrictions in her
daily life and entrepreneurial endeavors based
on the requirements of the order of supervision that her release is contingent upon.
Reporting Requirements
Stateless persons as well as other individuals with a final order of removal must comply
with an order of supervision as a condition of
their release from detention.118 Requirements
under an order of supervision generally include regular—sometimes monthly or even
weekly—in-person reporting to an immigration office which may be as far away as 50
miles or more; no travel outside the individual’s state of residence without a discretionary
grant of permission in advance; and the obligation to regularly contact embassies and
consulates to request travel documents or
permission to enter that country’s territory. In
some cases, stateless individuals have been
required to wear electronic ankle devices as
a means to track and further restrict their every move. Other than the necessity of an or-
25