2019
Statelessness & Citizenship Review
1(2)
Figure 7: ‘My Papers, My History’ — Travel
Document for Palestinian Refugees.
COLONIAL LEGACIES
The stateless art interlocutors, all stationed in Europe, use art to build a dialogue
on Europe’s historical colonial connection to the issue. Historical post-colonial
ties linking European colonial empires to the creation of stateless populations
show this deep European connection. Zahra Al-Barazi and Jason Tucker shed light
on how, when the Middle East and North Africa were separated into nation-states
under European colonial rule, they were largely split according to colonial
divisions, creating a plethora of stateless populations. 28 This was relevant for most
regions across the world under colonial rule. In this context, the experiences of
stateless populations are discussed as exterior to the European experience, only
considered when defined by suffering worthy of European rescue. Therefore,
stateless art interlocutors subvert this understanding of statelessness as
fundamentally non-European, that evokes only pity for the stateless ‘Other’,
evoking empathy rather than sympathy.
Firstly, stateless art interlocutors highlight these historical connections,
indicating a European responsibility in the foundation of stateless populations. For
example, Zaraa recounts a conversation with UK border guards: ‘I told them your
government is responsible for why I have this travel document’, creating a link to
European colonial history, Palestinian exodus, and his own personal plight.
Indeed, Zaraa often switches from the collective ‘we’ of stateless Palestinians to
‘I’ to recall his personal experience, showing how closely intertwined he considers
his own experience as a stateless individual to the geo-political history of his
28
Zahra Al-Barazi and Jason Tucker, ‘Challenging the Disunity of Statelessness in the Middle
East and North Africa’ in Tendayi Bloom, Katherine Tonkiss and Phillip Cole
(eds), Understanding Statelessness (Routledge 2017) 87, 88.
324