C.
74
SECTION I.B.2
EVERY CHILD’S RIGHT TO A NATIONALITY
The arguments and sub-arguments made thus far apply to all
individuals. Children, however, deserve special attention and
accordingly enjoy additional rights and safeguards. The African
Committee of Experts on the Rights and Welfare of the Child
(‘ACERWC’) rightly observed the following in this regard:
Statelessness is particularly devastating to children in the
realisation of their socio-economic rights such as access to health
care, and access to education. In sum, being stateless as a child is
generally antithesis to the best interests of children.113
The current Indian citizenship framework does not provide for
nationality to children born within the territory of India who
would otherwise be stateless. Prior to the 1986 amendment of the
Citizenship Act, every child born within Indian territory was
conferred Indian citizenship at the time of birth (with two rarely
applicable conditions that exist even today under section 3(2) of
the Act). The 1986 amendment imposed an additional requirement
that either of the child’s parents must be Indian citizens in order
to be eligible for Indian citizenship by birth (‘jus soli’). To further
restrict the jus soli principle, the 2003 amendment added yet
another condition that neither parent must be an ‘illegal migrant’.
Accordingly, the present law is not only in contravention of
several international legal instruments signed and ratified by
India, but also in contravention of customary international law
in this regard.
113
Institute for Human Rights and Development in Africa (IHRDA) and Open Society Justice Initiative (on
behalf of Children of Nubian Descent in Kenya) v Government of Kenya Comm no 002/Com/002/2009
(ACERWC, 22 March 2011).
SECURING CITIZENSHIP
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents