T H E G L O B A L S TAT E O F C I T I Z E N S H I P
Security of status
Citizenship is often described as a secure status: once a citizen, always a citizen. This security of status comes with
a guarantee that a person can always come back to their
country of origin. In most cases, being a citizen prevents the
state from expelling a person or extraditing them to another
country.
Yet in recent years, the status of citizenship has become ever
less secure. With the growing number of armed conflicts
and incidence of terrorism worldwide, many countries have
introduced provisions for withdrawing the citizenship of
a person on the basis of national security grounds. Over a
third of the world’s countries, including many European
states, can now strip a person of their citizenship when their
actions are seen as disloyal or threatening to state security.
Most of the provisions for stripping citizenship target persons who have naturalised, and not those who have been
born as citizens. This indicates that – for most immigrants
– the status of citizenship is not truly secure. Imagine two
people – one born a citizen, one naturalised - committing
the same act of treason against their state. While the ‘natural’
born citizen would be able to retain their citizenship, the naturalised one would lose it. This is discriminatory treatment.
A further issue with citizenship revocation is the widespread
absence of proper legal safeguards and protections against
statelessness. People who gave up their citizenship of origin
to be naturalised or people who the state considers to belong
elsewhere are at a particular risk.
2