of the Evaluation Team to speak with a wide array of actors “doing” diplomacy, particularly high-level
diplomacy. However, in the Dominican Republic, with PRM’s support, the Evaluation Team was able to
access current and former diplomats engaged in high-level diplomacy.
DATA AND FINDINGS
EQ1: TO WHAT EXTENT ARE PRM INVESTMENTS IN STATELESSNESS INITIATIVES—BOTH FINANCIAL
AND DIPLOMATIC—CONTRIBUTING TO THE PREVENTION AND REDUCTION OF STATELESSNESS AND
TO THE PROTECTION OF STATELESS PEOPLE?
5.1.1 Funding
The U.S. is the largest single donor to UNHCR. PRM funding supports the prevention and reduction of
statelessness and identification and protection of stateless people primarily through earmarked and
unearmarked contributions to UNHCR's appeals. PRM has also funded the GCENR through the WRC,
supported projects without a specific statelessness focus that worked on related issues (birth registration
and civil documentation) and commissioned research studies on statelessness.
Unearmarked funding.
UNHCR’s budget is organized around four Pillars: refugees, stateless persons, reintegration (of returning
refugees) and IDPs. The proportion of UNHCR’s overall expenditures allocated to Pillar II (stateless
persons) stayed between less than 1 percent to roughly 1.2 percent of UNHCR’s budget since the launch of
the #IBelong Campaign. Over the period of the evaluation there appeared to be a decrease in Pillar II
funding from 1.2 percent in 2014 to 1 percent in 2020.5 Most UNHCR country programs do not allocate
funds under Pillar II; of the three focus countries for this evaluation, only the Dominican Republic used
Pillar II. Funding from other budget pillars is also used by many UNHCR country operations to address
statelessness (e.g., in countries where stateless people are also refugees), so it is difficult to discern how
much funding is actually allocated for statelessness; however, it is clear that funding for statelessness is far
less than for other populations of concern. The Pillar system will be phased out of UNHCR’s practice and,
in the future, all populations of concern will be assisted out of the same protection budget.
In PRM’s contribution letter, PRM strongly encourages
UNHCR to spend an amount on statelessness commensurate
with its overall allocation. Discussions with UNHCR
management revealed that they felt strongly about keeping the
same funding arrangement with the U.S. However, through
interviews UNHCR’s management staff acknowledged that
UNHCR needed to rethink their overall fundraising strategy for
their work on statelessness, as illustrated through the sentiments
expressed by one high-level UNHCR staff in Box 1.
Box 1: Unearmarked Funding
“I can’t say earmarked [funding] is
something we can really consider in
UNHCR. We are always saying we don’t
want to earmark funds so we cannot start
now by saying that…. What we need to do is
fundraise more specifically for statelessness.
We don’t want the US to change the way they
do their funding, but we should seek more
funding for specific projects.”
In 2014, at the launch of the #IBelong Campaign, there were insufficient human and material resources
dedicated to work on statelessness within UNHCR. The budget for the campaign came from the existing
budget. The limited resources available have led to a perception that statelessness is the “poor step-cousin,
in terms of UNHCR’s refugee mandate,” as put by one high-level UNHCR staff.
PRM Earmarked funding for statelessness. Only a small amount of U.S. funding to UNHCR is earmarked
for statelessness activities. In 2020, PRM provided $571,053 in earmarked funding to support stateless
programming to maintain the momentum created by the global HLS (discussed at greater length later in
this report). In 2019, the HLS marked the midpoint in the #IBelong Campaign. There were a series of
regional convenings that brought together government, UN, and civil society actors, who collectively
committed to over 360 pledges towards statelessness eradication. The earmarked PRM funds are aimed at
providing small amounts to targeted UNHCR country operations to assist governments in implementing
5 Information on budgets by pillar between 2014-2020 can be found at Financials | Global Focus (unhcr.org)
4