Rethinking Statelessness from Within
zoning and governmental rigmarole which one may be accustomed to in Western
nations. In fact, most housing in Haiti is constructed by individual households.96
Such a system may reflect empowering dynamics of community, connection and
family, if not for the fact that the lack of government assistance and adequate
oversight created ‘generally poor infrastructure and inferior housing construction’
that left Haiti particularly vulnerable to natural hazards, such as floods or
earthquakes. 97 The 2010 earthquake damaged more than 300,000 homes,
permanently destroying 100,000 of these homes and forcing 1.3 million Haitians
into temporary shelters. 98 Tent cities, once a ‘stop-gap measure’
post-earthquake, 99 have become indicative of a greater trend in deficient
infrastructure in Haiti. The lack of government involvement pre-earthquake
continued post-earthquake, with the government failing to engage fruitfully in
rubble removal to allow homes to be rebuilt, even blocking necessary equipment
at the Dominican Republic border.100 Devastation at this scale was not by chance
or environmental unluckiness. Dupuy states that geologists had been warning the
government about the possibility of an earthquake and the subsequent harms that
one would pose to the already vulnerable state of the nation’s infrastructure for
years.101 Yet no preventative actions were taken and when an earthquake finally
did happen, the people of Haiti were forced to rely on the charity of the
international community.102 The instability caused by a lack of adequate, stable
housing negatively impacts Haitian individuals’ senses of belonging, community
and citizenship fulfilment. Without a stable sense of place, and the enduring
precarity associated with a lack of housing, the Haitian populace’s ability to
engage politically becomes severely hindered. Without the fulfilment of base
human needs, movement to the desired political activities described by Arendt —
voting and running for public office —103 or other political acts such as protest,
engaging with (ideally elected) politicians, writing to constituents or political art,
becomes inaccessible. Post-earthquake, struggling to fulfil the cyclical needs of
survival dominates day-to-day existence, meaning partaking in citizenship
fulfilment falls by the wayside.
This is demonstrated in a 2015 qualitative study investigating the impact of
social inequality and environmental factors on Haitians’ decisions to migrate to
Canada. This study by Amina Mezdour, Luisa Veronis and Robert McLeman
works to understand ‘how social inequality within Haiti intersects with
environmental conditions’ to motivate internal and international migration. 104
Many participants reiterated the theme of poor living conditions and infrastructure
in both regional and metropolitan Haiti. 105 Unfortunately, ‘overcrowding, air
96
Keith Crane et al, ‘Chapter Seven: Housing and Infrastructure’ in Building a More Resilient
Haitian State (RAND Corporation 2010) 87, 88.
97 Dupuy, ‘Beyond the Earthquake’ (n 7) 196.
98 Crane (n 96) 89.
99 ibid 87.
100 ibid 89.
101 Dupuy, ‘Beyond the Earthquake’ (n 7) 196.
102 ibid 195.
103 Hannah Arendt, ‘Reflections on Little Rock’ in Peter Baehr (ed), The Portable Hannah Arendt
(Penguin Books 2003) 237 (‘Arendt, “Reflections on Little Rock”’).
104 Amina Mezdour, Luisa Veronis and Robert McLeman, ‘Environmental Influences on Haitian
Migration to Canada and Connections to Social Inequality: Evidence from Ottawa-Gatineau
and Montreal’ in Robert McLeman, Jeanette Schade and Thomas Faist (eds), Environmental
Migration and Social Inequality (Springer International Publishing 2015) 103, 104.
105 ibid 107, 109.
141